Hi

Using MPro 9.01. I received an email with a couple of attachments. When I attempted to save one of them, I got the following error messages:

Reporter 2.73a (09 Mar 2021) List Thu 1st May 2025 18:54

18:20:03.69 ** WimpError ** from Messenger
Error : &00000000
Message: :SSD.$.Data.BB.Charity.2025.Print annual return | Charity Commi ssion/pdf - File name 'SCSI::SSD.$.Data.BB.Charity.2025.Print annual return | Charity Commission/pdf' not recognised
18:20:14.88 ** WimpError ** from Messenger
Error : &00000000
Message: :RamDisc0.$.Print annual return | Charity Commission/pdf - File
name 'RAM::RamDisc0.$.Print annual return | Charity Commission/pdf' not recognised

Reporter 2.73a (09 Mar 2021) Listed 5793 lines

I could not find a way to rename the offending attachment before saving,
and the save doesn't allow renaming. I had to forward the document to
myself, and pick it up on a PC in order to save it with a legal name.

Is there a way to handle this better please?

--
Alan Adams

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

On 1 May 2025 as I do recall,
Alan Adams wrote:

Hi

Using MPro 9.01. I received an email with a couple of attachments. When I attempted to save one of them, I got the following error messages:

Reporter 2.73a (09 Mar 2021) List Thu 1st May 2025 18:54

18:20:03.69 ** WimpError ** from Messenger
Error : &00000000
Message: :SSD.$.Data.BB.Charity.2025.Print annual return | Charity Commi
ssion/pdf - File name 'SCSI::SSD.$.Data.BB.Charity.2025.Print annual return | Charity Commission/pdf'
not recognised
18:20:14.88 ** WimpError ** from Messenger
Error : &00000000
Message: :RamDisc0.$.Print annual return | Charity Commission/pdf - File
name 'RAM::RamDisc0.$.Print annual return | Charity Commission/pdf' not recognised

Reporter 2.73a (09 Mar 2021) Listed 5793 lines

I could not find a way to rename the offending attachment before saving,
and the save doesn't allow renaming. I had to forward the document to
myself, and pick it up on a PC in order to save it with a legal name.

Is there a way to handle this better please?

Does it makes any difference if you do "Message->Extract All Parts" via
the menu as opposed to dragging a single attachment from the pane?

(I feel that there ought to be a way to control the name given to a file
being exported from MPro, just as you can rename files being attached to e-mails you are about to send, but I can't see one.)


--
Harriet Bazley == Loyaulte me lie ==

Micro Credo: Never trust a computer bigger than you can lift.

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

In message <2a0c4d165c.Alan@alan.adamshome.org.uk>
Alan Adams <alan@adamshome.org.uk> wrote:

Hi

Using MPro 9.01. I received an email with a couple of attachments. When I attempted to save one of them, I got the following error messages:

Reporter 2.73a (09 Mar 2021) List Thu 1st May 2025 18:54

18:20:03.69 ** WimpError ** from Messenger
Error : &00000000
Message: :SSD.$.Data.BB.Charity.2025.Print annual return | Charity Commi ssion/pdf - File name 'SCSI::SSD.$.Data.BB.Charity.2025.Print annual return | Charity Commission/pdf'
not recognised 18:20:14.88 ** WimpError ** from Messenger
Error : &00000000
Message: :RamDisc0.$.Print annual return | Charity Commission/pdf - File name 'RAM::RamDisc0.$.Print annual return | Charity Commission/pdf' not recognised

Reporter 2.73a (09 Mar 2021) Listed 5793 lines

I could not find a way to rename the offending attachment before saving,
and the save doesn't allow renaming. I had to forward the document to
myself, and pick it up on a PC in order to save it with a legal name.

Is there a way to handle this better please?

It looks to be that the filename contains spaces. In principle, they
could be changed to non-breaking spaces (&A0 instead of &20). I
believe that this technique is used elsewhere in RISC OS.

David

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

In message <2a0c4d165c.Alan@alan.adamshome.org.uk>
on 1 May 2025 Alan Adams wrote:

[snip]

I could not find a way to rename the offending attachment before saving,
and the save doesn't allow renaming. I had to forward the document to
myself, and pick it up on a PC in order to save it with a legal name.

Is there a way to handle this better please?

Yes, a very non-intuitive Ctrl-Adjust-double-click on the attachment icon brings up a save as box which allows you to pick a different name.

--
Matthew Phillips
Durham

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

On 25 May 2025 as I do recall,
Matthew Phillips wrote:

In message <2a0c4d165c.Alan@alan.adamshome.org.uk>
on 1 May 2025 Alan Adams wrote:

[snip]

I could not find a way to rename the offending attachment before saving, and the save doesn't allow renaming. I had to forward the document to myself, and pick it up on a PC in order to save it with a legal name.

Is there a way to handle this better please?

Yes, a very non-intuitive Ctrl-Adjust-double-click on the attachment icon brings up a save as box which allows you to pick a different name.

According to the manual ("The Message Display Window") it's just an Adjust-double-click, and that does seem to work - though I didn't know
about it, or else had forgotten!

--
Harriet Bazley == Loyaulte me lie ==

The fact that you're paranoid.... doesn't mean they're NOT out to get you.

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

In message <c37d752a5c.Matthew@sinenomine.co.uk>
Matthew Phillips <mnews@sinenomine.freeserve.co.uk> wrote:

In message <df62c2225c.harriet@bazleyfamily.co.uk>
on 25 May 2025 Harriet Bazley wrote:

On 25 May 2025 as I do recall,
Matthew Phillips wrote:

In message <2a0c4d165c.Alan@alan.adamshome.org.uk>
on 1 May 2025 Alan Adams wrote:

[snip]

I could not find a way to rename the offending attachment before saving, >>>> and the save doesn't allow renaming. I had to forward the document to
myself, and pick it up on a PC in order to save it with a legal name.

Is there a way to handle this better please?

Yes, a very non-intuitive Ctrl-Adjust-double-click on the attachment icon >>> brings up a save as box which allows you to pick a different name.

According to the manual ("The Message Display Window") it's just an
Adjust-double-click, and that does seem to work - though I didn't know
about it, or else had forgotten!

Ah, that's simpler! I should have checked the manual but usually I fumble around till I hit on something that works. It would be rather better if there was an option off a menu over the attachment icon, I feel. We could also do with a "Save All" option to put them all in a (new?) folder.

There is an "Extract all parts" on menu over the message to put everything
into a folder, is that what you want?



--
Chris Hughes

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

In message <df62c2225c.harriet@bazleyfamily.co.uk>
on 25 May 2025 Harriet Bazley wrote:

On 25 May 2025 as I do recall,
Matthew Phillips wrote:

In message <2a0c4d165c.Alan@alan.adamshome.org.uk>
on 1 May 2025 Alan Adams wrote:

[snip]

I could not find a way to rename the offending attachment before saving, >>> and the save doesn't allow renaming. I had to forward the document to
myself, and pick it up on a PC in order to save it with a legal name.

Is there a way to handle this better please?

Yes, a very non-intuitive Ctrl-Adjust-double-click on the attachment icon
brings up a save as box which allows you to pick a different name.

According to the manual ("The Message Display Window") it's just an Adjust-double-click, and that does seem to work - though I didn't know
about it, or else had forgotten!

Ah, that's simpler! I should have checked the manual but usually I fumble around till I hit on something that works. It would be rather better if
there was an option off a menu over the attachment icon, I feel. We could
also do with a "Save All" option to put them all in a (new?) folder.

--
Matthew Phillips
Durham

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)

In message <6a58782a5c.chris@mytardis>
on 9 Jun 2025 Chris Hughes wrote:

In message <c37d752a5c.Matthew@sinenomine.co.uk>
Matthew Phillips <mnews@sinenomine.freeserve.co.uk> wrote:

Ah, that's simpler! I should have checked the manual but usually I fumble >> around till I hit on something that works. It would be rather better if
there was an option off a menu over the attachment icon, I feel. We could >> also do with a "Save All" option to put them all in a (new?) folder.

There is an "Extract all parts" on menu over the message to put everything into a folder, is that what you want?

Thanks - I'd not spotted that. It also saves the text of the email
(including the HTML version if there is one) as well as actual
attachments, but it would be easy enough to delete those afterwards if not needed.

I think a user interface improvement would be to have a more attachment-specific menu over the attachments area, which would include
saving all attachements, stripping them, and saving individual attachments under new names. That would make it much harder for people not to
discover these features!

I see that the Save As box for saving an individual attachment is also available via Menu -> Goto -> Part.

--
Matthew Phillips
Durham

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)