• Re: Epoch accept request for plasma-dialer and spacebar

    From Soren Stoutner@21:1/5 to All on Sat Nov 30 17:15:21 2024
    Copy: debian-on-mobile-maintainers@alioth-lists.debian.net

    On Saturday, November 30, 2024 10:17:57 AM MST Marco Mattiolo wrote:
    Hi,

    I'm co-maintaining with Arnaud the Debian packaging of the plasma-mobile shell and a few related apps, in order for Debian to be provide this additional graphical environment choice on mobile devices.


    Plasma-dialer is the phone app, while Spacebar is the SMS app inside the plasma-mobile shell.

    Upstream developers of these 2 apps have recently moved [1][2][3]

    from the KDE apps' release numbering (year.month.revision, like 23.01.0
    that is the version now in Debian stable and sid for both apps)

    to the Plasma release numbering (major.intermediate.minor revision
    number, like 6.2.3 that is the Plasma version the Qt/KDE team has
    recently uploaded to sid).


    Therefore, the intended upgrade direction is from version 23.01.0 to the version 6.2.4, that isn't handled correctly by apt due to the new
    revision number being lower than the old one.

    In order to fix the upgrade process, I would like to add an epoch to the version number. I think this is the only way to handle this correctly,
    but I'm not so experienced so any hint is welcome.

    Is it fine for the Debian project to add the epoch to these 2 apps'
    version number?

    I would agree that this is an appropriate use of an epoch, and I can’t think of any other way to handle the situation.

    --
    Soren Stoutner
    soren@debian.org
    -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

    iQIzBAABCgAdFiEEJKVN2yNUZnlcqOI+wufLJ66wtgMFAmdLqpkACgkQwufLJ66w tgO8rQ/9GkmIFZ+8n31kmUtSuLg6NGxCNMCggmib93S8CnnT1hm+cJ6QoW31Fn7u NpvGCaJKGqzKXCgOhBuuekHefKfYdRwNw9sDr6lTmGbQSdiNKtjSZyXq1cTz/A1o KVAUIy06wnc7sqNjVf2ZQFNlIZlZd+D4Dce5S0cVtfeVjeAW7Dyk1BC4/z/Nv1yD FnzJue2ifXICLzzT0+yIdaAWXYAeDfTlIXxwpFarl8jRboJwZXrR/4s7i6fiWOQk wU3oFChfJPvQE7pkpOuYvInuxes6lREOVg34tcH+xBSB+G6dwUJssFwdJeYz/Bla MrqK6W6YzBmN9s6BjhhUk4TgUoKQDeRxarz+02fCtoFVYt2KP7xrV52+fO9UgkCa a5GmCymMcFkI1d2H0SWS1LLfikWV3jsX9kHstunY9JbbyIbuSBfAXh1aa6oFlPaD QabJQFtGARqLdncz8ALGJtWLHTcqHibzNC6Pm3ZFkBoCjTwLdpKa3I8hzWslB/3U BgInOjRqjZ1G/pmLtGGTICUqMNaT1lQ8xzM3Gig8YeRiwk7d1IJStBt0nFOwhbUk Q2WeVyZFVVtzbgGw4HYOiez3uiSNjucbSrvHgGIIxXqqfi9JGoeJ9ez3ArsK828B jMhx8+835ZPgS9N9LJGMqra+Ptu1IrqILn5Ty2yxKn4aXcTwOSk=
    =xyhJ
    -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Salvo Tomaselli@21:1/5 to All on Tue Dec 3 23:27:20 2024
    Copy: debian-on-mobile-maintainers@alioth-lists.debian.net

    I would agree that this is an appropriate use of an epoch, and I can’t think
    of any other way to handle the situation.

    Yeah if they don't do monotonic versioning I don't see an alternative either

    --
    Salvo Tomaselli

    "Io non mi sento obbligato a credere che lo stesso Dio che ci ha dotato di senso, ragione ed intelletto intendesse che noi ne facessimo a meno."
    -- Galileo Galilei

    https://ltworf.codeberg.page/
    -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

    iQIzBAABCAAdFiEEQnSLnnbYmXmeH74Us6fPDIAYhs8FAmdPhcgACgkQs6fPDIAY hs/xpw/9F65GKWGKlC5sNBnn1yvKuHxbB0MN0NAQSJhVRREVgD2inY1nFxgFf5mL x0K7Gq+ICH2fFs189LPDZxNnGvMqgO+iwRVlWRSl7YmAtj8YHrwfgGlbLesYxR+Y mGCppw24Y4sNyMMDC0VpZt6z8BiijqXfCT8DrHxcVSLp/Hdgv/0Q846yoaEztpY5 m1JDyqlgli66VRNXABrskaUiT2vvC1TTqKYKyo9p3yEs00pbeScuf92q8ChVJaAl q5lKrfkF2n2KHcWB9A105bbqxVx5CWMVG5tz13pkNEuPWcvPaK8Tlob3ljqr5r1t 8IvjDGDYOatncgx/TICsYrythucmxgNeFUiOpDWrGCU7uiNFUa4oZsCLSJXPv/Iz WmhQz7wDDnz4klpCaGA3oFBGFlrywUIb+MU3waJBRP3+P24Ba6d6YpxrCbOsnKR5 5dtBzsqewHrkAJiBsQOM4KKX8CeNBzXIQSjzQ/JedSOTE4nCKpaQB7bj00Jx7phL b398JvzPF/OjBsr1GzRxI1j5IdWknTfxs5BMp7lE5Sky1gKcx3t5MGkFBEhmitol dut67MOqo7PoYeqronmbRcqP18sQ5M55xo9qJMlkFCNJoKH4xI/+r9Bm1CTlFL7b zkVPuk1F1IH+CLV0as8Kb7uo0