Hi,
Does mentors "debexpo" apply different severity to the lintian tags?
I'm running lintian locally on testing, which has the same lintian
version as unstable, but I see 'P' or 'X' locally, then get 'Error' and 'Info' on mentors.d.n
This one: spelling-error-in-binary is Pedantic in the logs, in lintian-explain-tags and even here:
- https://udd.debian.org/lintian-tag/spelling-error-in-binary
- https://lintian.debian.org/tags/spelling-error-in-binary.html
but mentors shows Info
This one: source-is-missing is Experimental, but shows as Error on mentors.
Am I missing a config somewhere or is mentors doing this for a reason?
The mismatch is a bit annoying. Have to do a second upload and push it
to salsa too.
PS, I use "-EI --pedantic --profile debian" all the time.
On Wednesday, May 21, 2025 12:08:09 PM Mountain Standard Time Ahmad Khalifa
Does mentors "debexpo" apply different severity to the lintian tags?
I'm running lintian locally on testing, which has the same lintian
version as unstable, but I see 'P' or 'X' locally, then get 'Error' and
'Info' on mentors.d.n
This one: spelling-error-in-binary is Pedantic in the logs, in
lintian-explain-tags and even here:
- https://udd.debian.org/lintian-tag/spelling-error-in-binary
- https://lintian.debian.org/tags/spelling-error-in-binary.html
but mentors shows Info
This one: source-is-missing is Experimental, but shows as Error on mentors. >>
Am I missing a config somewhere or is mentors doing this for a reason?
The mismatch is a bit annoying. Have to do a second upload and push it
to salsa too.
PS, I use "-EI --pedantic --profile debian" all the time.
Mentors uses an old version of lintian. I am not sure which version it is, but in some cases it has different tags and in others it has different severities or different checks for the same tag.
This is not a unique problem with Mentors. A lot of Debian infrastructure runs lintian from either stable or oldstable, which causes consternation from time to time.
On 21/05/2025 21:11, Soren Stoutner wrote:Khalifa
On Wednesday, May 21, 2025 12:08:09 PM Mountain Standard Time Ahmad
mentors.Does mentors "debexpo" apply different severity to the lintian tags?
I'm running lintian locally on testing, which has the same lintian
version as unstable, but I see 'P' or 'X' locally, then get 'Error' and
'Info' on mentors.d.n
This one: spelling-error-in-binary is Pedantic in the logs, in
lintian-explain-tags and even here:
- https://udd.debian.org/lintian-tag/spelling-error-in-binary
- https://lintian.debian.org/tags/spelling-error-in-binary.html
but mentors shows Info
This one: source-is-missing is Experimental, but shows as Error on
is,
Am I missing a config somewhere or is mentors doing this for a reason?
The mismatch is a bit annoying. Have to do a second upload and push it
to salsa too.
PS, I use "-EI --pedantic --profile debian" all the time.
Mentors uses an old version of lintian. I am not sure which version it
but in some cases it has different tags and in others it has different severities or different checks for the same tag.
This is not a unique problem with Mentors. A lot of Debian infrastructure runs lintian from either stable or oldstable, which causes consternation from
time to time.
Ohh, it's older, not newer. I imagined udd would be the older one.
Strangely though, mentors did find a couple of Warnings that my local
lintian didn't.
Lintian has dropped some tags that were considered inaccurate. Some have changed priority, so unless you are displaying Pedantic or Experimental you will no longer see them. And others have had their checks modified to minimize false positives, so they may no longer flag for your code base.
I personally check locally with:
lintian -iIE --pedantic
Then I choose to ignore Pedantic and Experimental tags that I don’t feel apply
to my project.
Sysop: | Keyop |
---|---|
Location: | Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, UK |
Users: | 546 |
Nodes: | 16 (0 / 16) |
Uptime: | 167:00:42 |
Calls: | 10,385 |
Calls today: | 2 |
Files: | 14,057 |
Messages: | 6,416,529 |