• MEDIA: Is Custom King?

    From John D Groenveld@21:1/5 to All on Mon Oct 9 11:54:26 2023
    Claremont's Michael Anton on what number of the 8+B globe's top two
    quintiles Donald Trump will import into 350+M America and to what
    culture they will assimilate: <URL:https://americanmind.org/salvo/is-custom-king/>
    | Beyond this, there is another enormous problem that Gottfried never
    | mentions: how are we supposed to unite the 330 (350? more? who
    | knows?) million people living within the present borders of the
    | United States around a tradition that at least 100 million of them
    | did not grow up in and do not share? Even in the founding era,
    | tradition alone was deemed insufficient for uniting the new country.
    | Our disparities then--various Protestant sects, a few Catholics,
    | even fewer Jews, negligible ethnic differences--pale in comparison
    | to today's vaunted "diversity." I know Gottfried insists that the
    | founders did not resort to any airy abstractions in order to unite
    | English, Scot, Welsh, Irish, German, Catholic, mainline and
    | dissenting Protestant, and Jew--I disagree, but that too is old
    | ground by now. But even--especially--if Gottfried is right that
    | tradition is not merely the sufficient but the greatest possible
    | basis for public unity, how does he plan to amalgamate the, so to
    | speak, infinite traditions that, since the 1965 immigration act, now
    | reside in the United States?

    Does Susie Wiles see signs in her or Bill Stepien or Brad Parscale's
    polling that legacy American proles view diversity as a strength?
    John
    groenveld@acm.org
    --
    "I noted that the Save America PAC initially operated in a similar
    way as the NFTs. Save America texts and emails solicited donations
    from Trump supporters that told them to give money so the 2020
    election could be legally overturned. However..." - Pedro Gonzalez <URL:https://twitter.com/emeriticus/status/1603842900537868290>

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)