• Re: SE Asia railway revived

    From Ulf Kutzner@21:1/5 to Robert Lee on Wed Jan 19 10:01:38 2022
    Robert Lee schrieb am Mittwoch, 7. November 2001 um 13:22:28 UTC+1:
    Just for the record, all of continental southeast Asia's mainline raiwlays are metre-gauge. China is standard gauge with a few exceptions, the most important for this discussion being the old French line from the Vietnamese border at Laocai to Kunming. The line, the former Chemin de fer de l'Indo-Chine et du Yunnan, is metre-gauge and surprisingly busy when I was last in Kunming last year.
    It is true that the only gap is Phnom Phen to Saigon, but a good river route exists here and an adequate road. I suspect that part of the aim is the integration of Laos more fully into ASEAN, not to mention facilitating the exploitation of its natural resources by Thai generals, friends of PM Taksin and other assorted well-meaning and altruistic friends of the Lao people. (sorry if I'm laying on the sarcasm a bit thick here)
    A route through Laos will not be easy, although the bridge from Nong Khai
    (in THailand) across the Mekong to Vientiane already exists and has
    provision for a single rail track. But if Laos is hard, then the climb parallel to the Mekong up onto the Yunnan plateau will be the ral challenge. Exactly 100 years ago a (British) Govt of India surveyor described such a route as entailing a series of tunnels like Mt Cenis and bridges like the Menai Straits. Do you get the general idea? The engineering on the CFIY is utterly spectacular, and inlcudes the highest railway bridge in the world, and it takes the EASIEST route up to Yunnan. THe British abandoned their attempt to build a line from Burma into Yunnan at Lashio, before it even reached the Irrawaddy, which forms the border. THat line includes the
    world's SECOMD highest bridge.
    My opinion is that probably a line will be built into Laos, since there's likely to be money in it for someone, but I can't see the ascent into Yunnan happening in a hurry.

    Well, it took five years to build the line, which was opened six weeks ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boten%E2%80%93Vientiane_railway

    Regards, ULF

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From pH@21:1/5 to Ulf Kutzner on Thu Jan 20 01:30:02 2022
    On 2022-01-19, Ulf Kutzner <Ulf.Kutzner@web.de> wrote:
    Robert Lee schrieb am Mittwoch, 7. November 2001 um 13:22:28 UTC+1:
    Just for the record, all of continental southeast Asia's mainline raiwlays >> are metre-gauge. China is standard gauge with a few exceptions, the most
    important for this discussion being the old French line from the Vietnamese >> border at Laocai to Kunming. The line, the former Chemin de fer de
    l'Indo-Chine et du Yunnan, is metre-gauge and surprisingly busy when I was >> last in Kunming last year.

    When you say "metre-guage" does simply mean it's one-meter, ie: 39.37
    inches?

    pH in Aptos

    Yes, I could look it up...it's more fun to keep Usenet active.



    It is true that the only gap is Phnom Phen to Saigon, but a good river route >> exists here and an adequate road. I suspect that part of the aim is the
    integration of Laos more fully into ASEAN, not to mention facilitating the >> exploitation of its natural resources by Thai generals, friends of PM Taksin >> and other assorted well-meaning and altruistic friends of the Lao people.
    (sorry if I'm laying on the sarcasm a bit thick here)
    A route through Laos will not be easy, although the bridge from Nong Khai
    (in THailand) across the Mekong to Vientiane already exists and has
    provision for a single rail track. But if Laos is hard, then the climb
    parallel to the Mekong up onto the Yunnan plateau will be the ral challenge. >> Exactly 100 years ago a (British) Govt of India surveyor described such a
    route as entailing a series of tunnels like Mt Cenis and bridges like the
    Menai Straits. Do you get the general idea? The engineering on the CFIY is >> utterly spectacular, and inlcudes the highest railway bridge in the world, >> and it takes the EASIEST route up to Yunnan. THe British abandoned their
    attempt to build a line from Burma into Yunnan at Lashio, before it even
    reached the Irrawaddy, which forms the border. THat line includes the
    world's SECOMD highest bridge.
    My opinion is that probably a line will be built into Laos, since there's
    likely to be money in it for someone, but I can't see the ascent into Yunnan >> happening in a hurry.

    Well, it took five years to build the line, which was opened six weeks ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boten%E2%80%93Vientiane_railway

    Regards, ULF

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Ulf Kutzner@21:1/5 to All on Thu Jan 20 00:13:06 2022
    pH schrieb am Donnerstag, 20. Januar 2022 um 02:30:03 UTC+1:
    On 2022-01-19, Ulf Kutzner <Ulf.K...@web.de> wrote:
    Robert Lee schrieb am Mittwoch, 7. November 2001 um 13:22:28 UTC+1:
    Just for the record, all of continental southeast Asia's mainline raiwlays
    are metre-gauge. China is standard gauge with a few exceptions, the most >> important for this discussion being the old French line from the Vietnamese
    border at Laocai to Kunming. The line, the former Chemin de fer de
    l'Indo-Chine et du Yunnan, is metre-gauge and surprisingly busy when I was
    last in Kunming last year.
    When you say "metre-guage" does simply mean it's one-meter, ie: 39.37 inches?

    pH in Aptos

    Yes, I could look it up...it's more fun to keep Usenet active.
    It is true that the only gap is Phnom Phen to Saigon, but a good river route
    exists here and an adequate road. I suspect that part of the aim is the >> integration of Laos more fully into ASEAN, not to mention facilitating the
    exploitation of its natural resources by Thai generals, friends of PM Taksin
    and other assorted well-meaning and altruistic friends of the Lao people. >> (sorry if I'm laying on the sarcasm a bit thick here)
    A route through Laos will not be easy, although the bridge from Nong Khai >> (in THailand) across the Mekong to Vientiane already exists and has
    provision for a single rail track. But if Laos is hard, then the climb
    parallel to the Mekong up onto the Yunnan plateau will be the ral challenge.
    Exactly 100 years ago a (British) Govt of India surveyor described such a >> route as entailing a series of tunnels like Mt Cenis and bridges like the >> Menai Straits. Do you get the general idea? The engineering on the CFIY is
    utterly spectacular, and inlcudes the highest railway bridge in the world,
    and it takes the EASIEST route up to Yunnan. THe British abandoned their >> attempt to build a line from Burma into Yunnan at Lashio, before it even >> reached the Irrawaddy, which forms the border. THat line includes the
    world's SECOMD highest bridge.
    My opinion is that probably a line will be built into Laos, since there's >> likely to be money in it for someone, but I can't see the ascent into Yunnan
    happening in a hurry.

    Well, it took five years to build the line, which was opened six weeks ago.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boten%E2%80%93Vientiane_railway

    As far as I am concerned, I say metric gauge.


    Hm. „Metric gauge may refer to: Metre gauge, a rail gauge [...]“ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metric_gauge

    Given here in feet and inches: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metre-gauge_railway

    Regards, ULF

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From pH@21:1/5 to Ulf Kutzner on Fri Jan 21 00:53:30 2022
    On 2022-01-20, Ulf Kutzner <Ulf.Kutzner@web.de> wrote:
    pH schrieb am Donnerstag, 20. Januar 2022 um 02:30:03 UTC+1:
    On 2022-01-19, Ulf Kutzner <Ulf.K...@web.de> wrote:
    Robert Lee schrieb am Mittwoch, 7. November 2001 um 13:22:28 UTC+1:
    Just for the record, all of continental southeast Asia's mainline raiwlays
    are metre-gauge. China is standard gauge with a few exceptions, the most >> >> important for this discussion being the old French line from the Vietnamese
    border at Laocai to Kunming. The line, the former Chemin de fer de
    l'Indo-Chine et du Yunnan, is metre-gauge and surprisingly busy when I was
    last in Kunming last year.
    When you say "metre-guage" does simply mean it's one-meter, ie: 39.37
    inches?

    pH in Aptos

    Yes, I could look it up...it's more fun to keep Usenet active.
    It is true that the only gap is Phnom Phen to Saigon, but a good river route
    exists here and an adequate road. I suspect that part of the aim is the >> >> integration of Laos more fully into ASEAN, not to mention facilitating the
    exploitation of its natural resources by Thai generals, friends of PM Taksin
    and other assorted well-meaning and altruistic friends of the Lao people. >> >> (sorry if I'm laying on the sarcasm a bit thick here)
    A route through Laos will not be easy, although the bridge from Nong Khai >> >> (in THailand) across the Mekong to Vientiane already exists and has
    provision for a single rail track. But if Laos is hard, then the climb
    parallel to the Mekong up onto the Yunnan plateau will be the ral challenge.
    Exactly 100 years ago a (British) Govt of India surveyor described such a >> >> route as entailing a series of tunnels like Mt Cenis and bridges like the >> >> Menai Straits. Do you get the general idea? The engineering on the CFIY is
    utterly spectacular, and inlcudes the highest railway bridge in the world,
    and it takes the EASIEST route up to Yunnan. THe British abandoned their >> >> attempt to build a line from Burma into Yunnan at Lashio, before it even >> >> reached the Irrawaddy, which forms the border. THat line includes the
    world's SECOMD highest bridge.
    My opinion is that probably a line will be built into Laos, since there's >> >> likely to be money in it for someone, but I can't see the ascent into Yunnan
    happening in a hurry.

    Well, it took five years to build the line, which was opened six weeks ago.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boten%E2%80%93Vientiane_railway

    As far as I am concerned, I say metric gauge.


    Hm. „Metric gauge may refer to: Metre gauge, a rail gauge [...]“ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metric_gauge

    Given here in feet and inches: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metre-gauge_railway

    Regards, ULF

    Ah! Danke fur die auskunft. (Probably all mis-spelled....)

    Thank-you for the info....heretofore I had never heard of meter guage...it makes perfect sense, though.

    Thank-you
    pH

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Ulf Kutzner@21:1/5 to All on Thu Jan 20 19:19:22 2022
    pH schrieb am Freitag, 21. Januar 2022 um 01:53:32 UTC+1:

    Ah! Danke fur die auskunft. (Probably all mis-spelled....)

    No, just two points:

    We use a non-ASCII letter in für.

    Auskunft as a noun should be capitalised/capitalized (like names of days of the week,
    months, languages or adjectives referring to nationality or ethnicity in English).

    Regards, ULF

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From pH@21:1/5 to Ulf Kutzner on Fri Jan 21 17:46:29 2022
    On 2022-01-21, Ulf Kutzner <Ulf.Kutzner@web.de> wrote:
    pH schrieb am Freitag, 21. Januar 2022 um 01:53:32 UTC+1:

    Ah! Danke fur die auskunft. (Probably all mis-spelled....)

    No, just two points:

    We use a non-ASCII letter in für.

    Auskunft as a noun should be capitalised/capitalized (like names of days of the week,
    months, languages or adjectives referring to nationality or ethnicity in English).

    Regards, ULF

    Danke schoen.

    I will need to discover how to call up "umlauts" here....

    pH

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)