• Shout Factory bootleg DVDs: low bit rate

    From Pluted Pup@21:1/5 to All on Sat Mar 1 20:04:09 2025
    So I was bit recently by buying bootleg DVD sets on
    Ebay and Amazon (third party). With searching I
    find that Shout Factory used to have a FAQ on it's
    counterfeits, but they are derelict in not keeping
    the FAQ on their website. My anger was at Shout
    Factory and Sony because that's what I saw on the
    package and there were no warnings about the fakes
    on reviews on Amazon, as well as Sony's notorious
    favoring of highly compressed Mill Creek engineering
    for TV releases and has no problem with Mill Creek
    being distributed by Amazon under the name "Sony",
    aka the extremely processed Mill Creek Blu-Rays of
    I Dream Of Jeannie. Mill Creek always use double
    layered discs, and would ruin it by low bit-rate by not
    using enough discs while the bootlegs are low bit
    rate by being single layer.

    It's been a quarter of a century since the entertainment
    has been declaring that low bit rate is something
    that consumers should never worry about, an attitude
    that promotes and protects frauds.

    So what if the bootlegs were made ten years ago to compete
    in price alone with the formerly available legitimate
    products? The wrongness of the fraud then remains a
    fraud today. Here's the core of what makes the bootlegs a
    fraud:

    https://web.archive.org/web/20160412191509/https://www.shoutfactory.com/editorials/counterfeit-bootleg-media-faq

    5. Poor Video and Audio Quality

    Because the disc content has been compressed from a dual-layered source to a single-layered disc, bootlegs of our set often have terrible picture and audio quality, even when they play perfectly well on your equipment.

    7. Disc Size

    The best way to tell if your set is a bootleg is to check the size of one or more of the discs. The vast majority of our releases use dual-layered DVDs, which can hold up to 8.5 gigabytes of data. Bootleggers, on the other hand, use cheaper, single-layer
    discs, which can only hold up to 4.7 gigabytes of data. You can determine if your discs are single or dual-layered by checking their size in a DVD-ROM drive.

    In other words, the bootlegs are defrauding consumers by not
    disclosing that they are bootlegs. In order to avoid
    fraud the sellers and manufacturers of the bootlegs must
    have labels like this "WARNING: these bootleg DVDS have only
    half the bit rate of the original".

    both fully returned and refunded, but pushed me into buying
    a used set of the real thing at more than twice the price
    of the half bit rate garbage. Price alone does not designate
    quality and the unwatchably low bit rate fakes make it
    harder to find the real thing, which is out of print.

    Pressed DVDs, large sets, do not qualify as the real if their
    bit rate has been cut in half. The industry has poo poo'ed
    bit rates for a long time and have packaged their stuff
    with the strategy of "keep the customer ignorant", so
    fostering the short sited legit makers to fail to point
    point out that it is exactly the issue of bit rate that
    demerits the bootlegs and causes customers to say, as they
    so often say "oh no Shout Factory and Sony go down to only
    1.5 bps for their theme songs now".

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)