XPost: rec.arts.startrek.misc, rec.arts.startrek.fandom, rec.arts.tv
XPost: can.arts.sf

AI/LLM Reviews of Star Trek - The motion picture
based http://www.chakoteya.net/movies/movie1.html
and rated out of 10

Google Gemini

"Star Trek: The Motion Picture" (ST:TMP) marked
the franchise's ambitious leap from television
to the big screen, aiming for a grand, philosophical
science fiction epic. It reunited the beloved original
cast for a journey into the unknown, but its execution
proved to be a divisive experience for many.

Plot Overview:

The film opens with a mysterious and immensely powerful
alien entity, V'Ger, rapidly approaching Earth, destroying
everything in its path. Admiral James T. Kirk, eager to
reclaim command, takes over the refurbished USS Enterprise
from Captain Spock, who is struggling with his human emotions
after an attempt at Kolinahr. The crew, many of whom are new
to the Enterprise or have been away from space for years,
must race to intercept V'Ger and understand its intentions
before it reaches Earth and destroys all carbon-based life.
Their journey involves navigating V'Ger's vast, intricate
interior, confronting its logical yet destructive nature,
and ultimately discovering its surprising origin and purpose.

Strengths:

Visual Ambition:
The film is undeniably a visual spectacle for its time.
The long, lingering shots of the Enterprise and V'Ger's
immense structures showcase a commitment to grand-scale
science fiction. The special effects, while occasionally
dated by modern standards, were groundbreaking and aimed
to convey a sense of awe and wonder.

Philosophical Depth: ST:TMP leans heavily
into the philosophical questions that Star Trek was known
for. V'Ger's quest for its creator and its inability
to comprehend organic life raises profound questions
about existence, purpose, and the nature of intelligence.

Return of the Original Cast: Seeing Kirk, Spock, McCoy,
and the rest of the Enterprise crew back together
on the bridge was a significant draw for fans.
The film attempts to explore their individual evolutions
and challenges after years apart.

Jerry Goldsmith's Score: The musical score by Jerry
Goldsmith is iconic and majestic, perfectly capturing
the grandeur and mystery of space. It remains one of the
most celebrated aspects of the film.

Weaknesses:Pacing: This is arguably the film's
most significant weakness. The pacing is notoriously slow,
with numerous extended sequences dedicated to showcasing
the Enterprise and V'Ger's interior. What was intended
as awe often translates into tedium for many viewers.

Lack of Action/Drama: Compared to later Star Trek films,
ST:TMP is light on traditional action. The conflict is
primarily intellectual and philosophical, which, while
true to Star Trek's roots, didn't always translate
well to a blockbuster format.

V'Ger's Motivations/Resolution: While the philosophical
themes are a strength, V'Ger's ultimate origin
and its desire to merge with its creator can feel convoluted
or underwhelming to some. The resolution, while conceptually
interesting, lacks emotional punch.

Character Portrayals: While the cast's return was a strength,
some characters feel underutilized or slightly off.
Kirk's initial arrogance and Spock's detached Kolinahr
struggle, while intentional, can make them less relatable.

Dialogue: Some of the dialogue, particularly the technobabble,
can be dense and dry.

Overall Impression:"

Star Trek: The Motion Picture" is a flawed
but fascinating film. It's a bold artistic
statement that prioritizes intellectual curiosity
and visual grandeur over fast-paced action. It attempts
to be a thinking person's science fiction epic,
and in its best moments, it succeeds in evoking
a sense of wonder and exploring deep philosophical questions.
However, its glacial pacing and sometimes sterile character
interactions prevent it from being a universally beloved
entry in the franchise. It's a film that demands patience
but rewards those who appreciate its unique vision.

Rating: 6/10

ChatGPt

**Review: *Star Trek: The Motion Picture* (1979)**
**Rating: ★★★★☆ (7/10)**
[*Transcript: chakoteya.net – The Motion Picture*] (http://www.chakoteya.net/movies/movie1.html)

---

### **Summary:**

*Star Trek: The Motion Picture* marked the cinematic
debut of the franchise, reuniting the original
Enterprise crew to confront a mysterious, godlike
alien entity approaching Earth. The crew soon
discovers that the threat, known as V’Ger,
is in fact a long-lost Earth probe that has
evolved into something vast
and sentient — and is searching for its creator.

---

### **Review:**

**Visuals and Scope:**
Robert Wise’s direction gives the film
a sense of scale and grandeur previously unseen
in the franchise. With stunning model work,
immersive sound design, and Jerry Goldsmith’s
now-iconic score, *The Motion Picture*
feels like *Star Trek* aiming
for the heavens — literally and metaphorically.
The slow, lingering shots of the Enterprise
and the massive alien cloud underscore
a cinematic ambition influenced
by *2001: A Space Odyssey*.

**Themes and Ideas:**

The film delves into heady concepts:
the nature of consciousness, machine evolution,