XPost: rec.arts.startrek.current, rec.arts.startrek.fandom, rec.arts.tv
XPost: can.arts.sf
Ai LLM Reviews of Star Trek The Next Generation - Future Imperfect
Google Gemini
Plot Synopsis
The episode begins with Commander Riker leading
an away team on a planet, where he is knocked
unconscious by a strange gas. When he awakens,
he is shocked to find himself in sickbay, where
he is told that 16 years have passed. He is now
the captain of the Enterprise, and Data is his
first officer and an admiral. Riker's son,
Jean-Luc, is on board, and his former holodeck
character, Minuet, is now a real person
and his partner.
Riker is initially disoriented but accepts
his new reality, though he quickly notices
inconsistencies. He finds his son distant
and strange. He is told that they are on
the brink of war with the Romulans,
and he must lead the Enterprise into a battle he
knows nothing about. As he struggles to adapt,
Riker's suspicions grow. He realises that the
events are too perfect and too convenient. When
he attempts to access the ship's log and finds it
manipulated, he understands that something
is very wrong.
He finally confronts his "son," who reveals himself
to be an alien entity named Ethan. Ethan, a lonely
life form, had created the entire scenario to test
Riker and decide if he was a suitable friend.
The entire reality was a lie, and Ethan had created
it all to end his own solitude. The real away team
is found safe, and Riker and the crew return
to normal, leaving behind the memory of a future
that never was.
Strengths
Psychological Thriller: The episode is a
masterclass in psychological suspense. It keeps
the audience guessing and creates genuine
tension as Riker tries to figure out what
is real and what is not.
Emotional Depth: The episode provides
a fascinating look into Riker's emotional
landscape. We see his confusion, fear,
and eventual determination to uncover the truth.
The moments with his "son" are particularly
touching and make the final reveal all the more impactful.
A Unique Sci-Fi Twist: The resolution of the plot,
revealing the lonely alien entity, is a classic
Star Trek trope but is executed with emotional
weight and a fresh perspective. The episode is not
about a simple threat but about a profound
act of loneliness.
Weaknesses
The resolution, while emotionally resonant,
is a bit abrupt. Some viewers might wish for
a more detailed explanation of Ethan's powers
and existence.
Overall Impression
"Future Imperfect" is a standout episode for its
clever, character-driven plot. It's a wonderful
example of a mind-bending sci-fi mystery that
asks profound questions about identity, reality,
and human connection. It showcases Riker's
intelligence and resilience, proving that he is
a capable leader and a deeply empathetic individual.
Rating: 9/10
ChatGPT
Here’s a review of **“Star Trek: The Next
Generation” — *Future Imperfect*** (Season 4,
Episode 8), based on the script
from [chakoteya.net](
http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/182.htm),
plus insights from critics and fans:
---
## Summary
Riker, Worf, and Geordi investigate a mysterious
planet; suddenly, Riker awakens to find himself
16 years in the future. He’s now Captain of the
Enterprise, Picard is an Admiral, and the
crew—including Worf and Data—haven't aged.
Riker, suffering from memory loss, gradually
realises his "future" is a fabricated simulation
designed to trick him into sharing Federation
secrets. The illusion is powered by a lonely
alien child named Ethan (aka Barash), who just
wanted real company—even if it meant creating
a false reality. Riker ultimately helps Ethan
escape to the real Enterprise.
([Wikipedia][1], [Den of Geek][2], [Thoughts From the Mountain Top][3])
---
## What Works
* **Compelling "What If" Scenario**
Imagining Riker as future Captain—complete
with altered crew dynamics and a son—is
absorbing and creates compelling
emotional dissonance.
([Den of Geek][2], [Thoughts From the Mountain Top][3])
* **Thrilling Mystery and Revelations**
As