XPost: rec.arts.tv
ndalized just hours after expelling MPP
(Member of Provincial Parlia
Rightists condone violence as a solution. They are nothing but violent, uncivilized savages who should be shot like dogs if they step out of line.
Underrecognized: Extremist murders are usually from right-wing actors
Analysis by Philip Bump
National columnist
February 28, 2023 at 2:02 p.m. EST
Even before the attack at the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, even further
back than the Trump administration, federal authorities have been fretting about the threat of violence committed by domestic extremists. The idea
that people motivated by extreme political ideologies (or conspiracy
theories like QAnon) might commit acts of violence has been a central
driver of homeland-security considerations. After Jan. 6 and with the inauguration of President Biden, that increased. Research has shown,
though, that it’s right-wing ideologies that are far more likely to be
behind deadly acts of violence. And other research has shown that most Americans think of extremist violence in inaccurately bipartisan terms.
[Sign up for How To Read This Chart, a weekly data newsletter from Philip
Bump] In May, YouGov conducted a poll for Yahoo News measuring where
Americans put the blame for extremist murders. YouGov asked people to say
how many such killings were committed by left-wing or right-wing
extremists, finding that only a fraction of Americans viewed one side as
more likely to engage in such violence. Most 2020 Trump voters said that
more than half of murders linked to extremism were committed by left-wing actors; most Democrats and Biden voters said the same of right-wing
extremists. In total, only 18 percent of respondents said that almost all extremist murders were a function of right-wing actors. Another 21 percent
said that more than half were. Data released by the ADL last week shows
the reality. Over the past decade (the period included in YouGov’s poll),
96 percent of incidents in which extremists killed someone were committed
by people motivated by right-wing ideologies. More than three-quarters of
the resulting deaths — 335 of 444 — were linked to right-wing actors.
We’re not talking about a lot of incidents, happily. In fact, the number
of incidents has declined in recent years. From 2017 to 2019, the country averaged 24 incidents a year, which fell to 18 on average from 2020 to
2022. The average number of deaths in those periods fell from 51 to 27 annually. But the motivations for the incidents remain lopsided. In the
past five years, there have been three deaths linked to left-wing
extremists. There have been 176 linked to right-wing ones. The only reason
that right-wing extremists aren’t responsible for a greater percentage of deaths in the past decade is because of extremists acting in response to a radical Islamist ideology. If we consider only left- and right-wing
extremists in the past decade, 95 percent of deaths tracked by the ADL are
a function of right-wing extremists. Ten of the deaths that occurred in
2022 occurred at the mass shooting at a grocery store in a Black
neighborhood of Buffalo. This comports with the recent pattern, according
to the ADL: “Attacks by right-wing extremists were driven primarily by
white supremacist attacks against racial and religious minorities.” This
data is useful because it offers a direct point of comparison with the
views measured in YouGov’s poll. More than half of murders linked to
extremism in the past decade were a function of right-wing actors — as
about 4 in 10 Americans recognize. Only 4 percent were linked to left-wing actors, despite 47 percent of Republicans being confident that left-wing extremists committed more than half of those acts. It’s easy to identify
some possible reasons. President Donald Trump and his allies in the conservative media cast the unrest that occurred in the summer of 2020 in apocalyptic terms and, particularly after the Capitol riot, drew a false equivalence between extremists on both sides. Trump also isolated “antifa”
— a nebulously organized group of anti-fascist activists — as a central
violent threat to the country, despite federal officials understanding
that the real danger lay elsewhere. In other words, it’s safe to assume
that a combination of ideological loyalty and partisan spin worked.
There’s a reality about who commits these acts. And there’s a concerted, successful effort to muddy that reality.
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)