of the original dates of the writing of the songs?
Thanks Leo...no, I guess it's kind of a different thing.
I was looking for more like, Blowin' in the Wind written out for the
first time, on paper, he said it took 10 minutes, and then, a date. For
all the songs....wondering when they came into being, if a date could be
said to be given.
like i do pretty much, for my little pieces, which don't take that long
to write, usually.
Thanks Leo...no, I guess it's kind of a different thing.
I was looking for more like, Blowin' in the Wind written out for the
first time, on paper, he said it took 10 minutes, and then, a date. For
all the songs....wondering when they came into being, if a date could be
said to be given.
like i do pretty much, for my little pieces, which don't take that long
to write, usually.
LeoK wrote:
Further, some of Bob Dylan's earlier songs were inspired from rumors.
If the journalist Robert Shelton or Suze Rotolo (both deceased) among
others maybe could give some hint. -And why not ask "HIM SELF"
straight from the horse's mouth. (Joking..!!)
To my understanding there may be some "higher" "people" involved
into some of the rumors linked to some early Dylan songs.
(Including Blowin' in the Wind.)
//
---
Detta e-postmeddelande har sökts igenom efter virus med
antivirusprogram
från Avast.
https://www.avast.com/antivirus
i don't understand what you mean by songs "inspired from rumors," nor
see how that could possibly be any kind of answer to the inquiry as to records of the first writings or typings of the songs, with some kind of
date on them, or known date attributed to them.
can you please explain/clarify these two things, especially the first
one?
btw, thanks about the april mention. i think i knew that a long time
ago, and forgot. it sort of rang a bell, i THINK. maybe...maybe not.
yes, definitely the cruelest month...makes me wonder about sad-eyed lady....when THAT was written!!!! i hate that song. simply sadistic, or masochistic, depending on your point of view.
"cheesetray" <roach4994@gmail.com> wrote in message news:facfd4583b3dad2d22fef80f2e40f83a@www.novabbs.com...
LeoK wrote:
Further, some of Bob Dylan's earlier songs were inspired from rumors.
If the journalist Robert Shelton or Suze Rotolo (both deceased) among
others maybe could give some hint. -And why not ask "HIM SELF"
straight from the horse's mouth. (Joking..!!)
To my understanding there may be some "higher" "people" involved
into some of the rumors linked to some early Dylan songs.
(Including Blowin' in the Wind.)
//
---
Detta e-postmeddelande har sökts igenom efter virus med
antivirusprogram
från Avast.
https://www.avast.com/antivirus
i don't understand what you mean by songs "inspired from rumors," nor
see how that could possibly be any kind of answer to the inquiry as to
records of the first writings or typings of the songs, with some kind of
date on them, or known date attributed to them.
can you please explain/clarify these two things, especially the first
one?
btw, thanks about the april mention. i think i knew that a long time
ago, and forgot. it sort of rang a bell, i THINK. maybe...maybe not.
yes, definitely the cruelest month...makes me wonder about sad-eyed
lady....when THAT was written!!!! i hate that song. simply sadistic, or
masochistic, depending on your point of view.
//
It's rather well know among Dylan specialists or researchers that some
of his songs were inspired from rumors. Bjorner does mention this in
his folio-writings, especially if the lyrics in mind was rumor based.
So, yes, Dylan uses rumors in his earlier songs, the issue is more from
where they are coming. Probably only Dylan can answer on this.
The second issue of yours I can only refer to Bjorner again (if not Dylan), who is one of the most outstanding Dylan fan with an exceptional folio.
Still it's most tricky to go through all this writing of Bob's history of
the actual creation moments of the songs. -And only some songs are
reported in this manner.
Concerning the month of "Sad Eyed Lady.." writing you may look
in the www.azlyrics.com on the internet for to get the year, then maybe
look into the Bjorner page for that year to get the month.
It's a bit tricky, though.
HI Leo,
Okay, look. I STILL don't know what you mean by songs inspired by
rumors.
Can you cite even just one example, of a rumor, or rumors, which then "inspired" a specific song, and name that tune, to help me understand to
what you are referring?
You can take as many notes as you like, to respond, i have nothing else
to do. I'm not going anywhere, old friend. Don't you know me by now?
Btw, have you finally gotten home from work? Your dog was waiting
faithfully for you the whole time, the poor thing. Like fire and ice, if
you must know.
Peace Out.
Just call me....oh.....Barry's Big Fat Baby, or something, having a
truly extra specially annoying day....now heading into day two without
my medicine....
"LeoK" <1234@567.net> wrote in message news:v3hefq$3a19c$1@dont-email.me...
"cheesetray" <roach4994@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:facfd4583b3dad2d22fef80f2e40f83a@www.novabbs.com...
LeoK wrote:
Further, some of Bob Dylan's earlier songs were inspired from rumors.
If the journalist Robert Shelton or Suze Rotolo (both deceased) among
others maybe could give some hint. -And why not ask "HIM SELF"
straight from the horse's mouth. (Joking..!!)
To my understanding there may be some "higher" "people" involved
into some of the rumors linked to some early Dylan songs.
(Including Blowin' in the Wind.)
//
---
Detta e-postmeddelande har sökts igenom efter virus med
antivirusprogram
från Avast.
https://www.avast.com/antivirus
i don't understand what you mean by songs "inspired from rumors," nor
see how that could possibly be any kind of answer to the inquiry as to
records of the first writings or typings of the songs, with some kind of >>> date on them, or known date attributed to them.
can you please explain/clarify these two things, especially the first
one?
btw, thanks about the april mention. i think i knew that a long time
ago, and forgot. it sort of rang a bell, i THINK. maybe...maybe not.
yes, definitely the cruelest month...makes me wonder about sad-eyed
lady....when THAT was written!!!! i hate that song. simply sadistic, or
masochistic, depending on your point of view.
"LeoK" <1234@567.net> wrote in message news:v3heru$3a30i$1@dont-email.me...
"LeoK" <1234@567.net> wrote in message news:v3hefq$3a19c$1@dont-email.me... >>>
"cheesetray" <roach4994@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:facfd4583b3dad2d22fef80f2e40f83a@www.novabbs.com...
LeoK wrote:
Further, some of Bob Dylan's earlier songs were inspired from rumors. >>>>> If the journalist Robert Shelton or Suze Rotolo (both deceased) among >>>>> others maybe could give some hint. -And why not ask "HIM SELF"
straight from the horse's mouth. (Joking..!!)
To my understanding there may be some "higher" "people" involved
into some of the rumors linked to some early Dylan songs.
(Including Blowin' in the Wind.)
//
---
Detta e-postmeddelande har sökts igenom efter virus med
antivirusprogram
från Avast.
https://www.avast.com/antivirus
i don't understand what you mean by songs "inspired from rumors," nor
see how that could possibly be any kind of answer to the inquiry as to >>>> records of the first writings or typings of the songs, with some kind of >>>> date on them, or known date attributed to them.
can you please explain/clarify these two things, especially the first
one?
btw, thanks about the april mention. i think i knew that a long time
ago, and forgot. it sort of rang a bell, i THINK. maybe...maybe not.
yes, definitely the cruelest month...makes me wonder about sad-eyed
lady....when THAT was written!!!! i hate that song. simply sadistic, or >>>> masochistic, depending on your point of view.
//
Well, if we talk about this song..
I too am a bit reluctant to this song... To my understanding or imagination it was some type of farewell to Joan Baez who obviously was interested
in Bob. (Some type of harsh jump to Sara Lownds which he met in 1965
and the "Sad-Eyed Lady.." was some type of half-official statement.)
The most probable reason was that Sara was pregnant when this song
was written, February 1966, - Bob had almost no choice.)
Maybe this is gossiping, still interesting..
(One can still get these "facts" from the Bjorner/Dylan folio.)
I think Bob wrote some, stole some, bought some and was given some…
"cheesetray" <roach4994@gmail.com> wrote in message news:bf9e17fd8cfea33f85d787fedaa11551@www.novabbs.com...
of the original dates of the writing of the songs?
Think there are several such records, at least one that I know of:
https://www.bjorner.com/chronologies.htm
He was a Swedish most dedicated Dylan "researcher".
One can read of him (Olof Björner) on Wikipedia also.
The link is his own webpage.
Take care
LeoK
---
Detta e-postmeddelande har sökts igenom efter virus med
antivirusprogram
från Avast.
https://www.avast.com/antivirus
| Sysop: | Keyop |
|---|---|
| Location: | Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, UK |
| Users: | 498 |
| Nodes: | 16 (2 / 14) |
| Uptime: | 57:26:46 |
| Calls: | 9,812 |
| Files: | 13,754 |
| Messages: | 6,190,981 |