• Do Supermassive Black Holes Merge?

    From jillery@21:1/5 to All on Thu Aug 17 01:30:47 2023
    Rebecca Smethurst aka Dr. Becky is an astrophysicist specializing in
    research on Supermassive Black Holes aka SMBHs, arbitrarily defined as
    having at least 10^5 solar masses.

    The following is a 16-minute Youtube video that describes an
    interesting conundrum about SMBHs:

    <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6tXIoViA_0g>

    Short version: There is good evidence that almost all galaxies have
    SMBHs near their centers, and their masses are strongly correlated to
    the size of their associated galaxies, which suggests they co-evolved.
    There is also good evidence that about 10% of galaxies have merged
    with at least one other of about the same size in their lifetime, as
    Andromeda and Milky Way are expected to do in the next few billion
    years. This suggests these merged galaxies have either:

    1. multiple SMBHs, or
    2. the SMBHs merged into one.

    The conundrum is the math implies the SMBH's can't get closer to each
    other than about a parsec within the age of the universe. In the
    process of orbiting ever closer to each other, the SMBHs should kick
    out from the merged galaxies objects that would otherwise reduce their
    orbital velocity and allow them to continue to move closer to each
    other. Without these objects, the SMBHs can't slow down and so can't
    get closer. OTOH merging black holes are the only known way to create
    SMBHs.

    I have previously posted links which discuss Pulsar Timing Arrays,
    which can detect gravitational waves created by merging SMBHs. The
    Laser Interferometer Space Antenna aka LISA is also designed to
    directly detect the extremely long wavelength gravitational waves of
    merging SMBHs. However, this is an extremely complex and expensive
    system, and is scheduled to be launched in 2037. Considering how many
    times JWST was delayed, I would be surprised if LISA was launched
    before 2050.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From jillery@21:1/5 to All on Thu Aug 17 07:21:06 2023
    On Thu, 17 Aug 2023 01:30:47 -0400, jillery <69jpil69@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    Sent to wrong froup. My bad.

    Rebecca Smethurst aka Dr. Becky is an astrophysicist specializing in
    research on Supermassive Black Holes aka SMBHs, arbitrarily defined as
    having at least 10^5 solar masses.

    The following is a 16-minute Youtube video that describes an
    interesting conundrum about SMBHs:

    <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6tXIoViA_0g>

    Short version: There is good evidence that almost all galaxies have
    SMBHs near their centers, and their masses are strongly correlated to
    the size of their associated galaxies, which suggests they co-evolved.
    There is also good evidence that about 10% of galaxies have merged
    with at least one other of about the same size in their lifetime, as >Andromeda and Milky Way are expected to do in the next few billion
    years. This suggests these merged galaxies have either:

    1. multiple SMBHs, or
    2. the SMBHs merged into one.

    The conundrum is the math implies the SMBH's can't get closer to each
    other than about a parsec within the age of the universe. In the
    process of orbiting ever closer to each other, the SMBHs should kick
    out from the merged galaxies objects that would otherwise reduce their >orbital velocity and allow them to continue to move closer to each
    other. Without these objects, the SMBHs can't slow down and so can't
    get closer. OTOH merging black holes are the only known way to create
    SMBHs.

    I have previously posted links which discuss Pulsar Timing Arrays,
    which can detect gravitational waves created by merging SMBHs. The
    Laser Interferometer Space Antenna aka LISA is also designed to
    directly detect the extremely long wavelength gravitational waves of
    merging SMBHs. However, this is an extremely complex and expensive
    system, and is scheduled to be launched in 2037. Considering how many
    times JWST was delayed, I would be surprised if LISA was launched
    before 2050.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Popping Mad@21:1/5 to jillery on Thu Aug 31 20:36:25 2023
    On 8/17/23 01:30, jillery wrote:
    Rebecca Smethurst aka Dr. Becky is an astrophysicist specializing in
    research on Supermassive Black Holes aka SMBHs, arbitrarily defined as
    having at least 10^5 solar masses.


    When one of those struck the earth it killed all the dinosaurs.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)