Athel Cornish-Bowden wrote:
[---just another symptom of the D.I.D. system---]
So people aren't labeling actions as objects -- nouns -- because
they are and that makes sense and they're not it doing plus there's
nothing wrong with it...
"Tools" are nouns, objects. If you can't show we 500,000 year old
Chimp tools, 1 million year old Chimp tools then Chimps don't
use tools. They engage in actions.
The clue for you lunatics is that you have to witness the action
in order for you to imagine a tool. This is the clue that you're > losing bladder control over a verb, not a noun.
JTEM is my hero wrote:
AN adult is talking, johnjohn, go play until dinner.
Pro Plyd <invalide@invalid.invalid> wrote:
JTEM is my hero wrote:JTEM makes Glenn seem rather cordial, intellectual, and humane by
AN adult is talking, johnjohn, go play until dinner.
comparison. He’s pretty much a crank and shitposter. Most people seem to >ignore him as he’s also a vampire that feeds off negativity. He’s also a >narcissist and I’ve given the kook more attention than he deserves.
Jonathan would be preferable. Sadly Ray is no longer with us, at least in
the sense of posting. Which side of the ground he’s on has never been >confirmed to my knowledge.
JTEM is my hero wrote:Verbing weirds language. -Calvin
Athel Cornish-Bowden wrote:
[---just another symptom of the D.I.D. system---]
So people aren't labeling actions as objects -- nouns -- because
they are and that makes sense and they're not it doing plus there's nothing wrong with it...
"Tools" are nouns, objects. If you can't show we 500,000 year oldThey're building a building. One word used as both noun and verb.
Chimp tools, 1 million year old Chimp tools then Chimps don't
use tools. They engage in actions.
The clue for you lunatics is that you have to witness the action
in order for you to imagine a tool. This is the clue that you're > losing bladder control over a verb, not a noun.
Athel Cornish-Bowden wrote:
[---just another symptom of the D.I.D. system---]
So people aren't labeling actions as objects -- nouns -- because
they are and that makes sense and they're not it doing plus there's
nothing wrong with it...
"Tools" are nouns, objects. If you can't show we 500,000 year old
Chimp tools, 1 million year old Chimp tools then Chimps don't
use tools. They engage in actions.
The clue for you lunatics is that you have to witness the action
in order for you to imagine a tool. This is the clue that you're
losing bladder control over a verb, not a noun.
If Chimps don't use tools
On Friday, July 28, 2023 at 9:35:55 PM UTC-7, Pro Plyd wrote:
JTEM is my hero wrote:Verbing weirds language. -Calvin
Athel Cornish-Bowden wrote:They're building a building. One word used as both noun and verb.
[---just another symptom of the D.I.D. system---]
So people aren't labeling actions as objects -- nouns -- because
they are and that makes sense and they're not it doing plus there's
nothing wrong with it...
"Tools" are nouns, objects. If you can't show we 500,000 year old
Chimp tools, 1 million year old Chimp tools then Chimps don't
use tools. They engage in actions.
The clue for you lunatics is that you have to witness the action
in order for you to imagine a tool. This is the clue that you're > losing bladder control over a verb, not a noun.
jillery wrote:
If Chimps don't use tools
Chimps don't use tools, you frigging idiot. Pretending Chimps use
JTEM is my hero wrote:
jillery wrote:
If Chimps don't use tools
Chimps don't use tools, you frigging idiot. Pretending Chimps use
Termite fishing. Cracking nuts. Leaf sponges. Water dipping (for
drinking).
You're a well trained dog. You've proven that. Now try to think.
You'll be wrong, but maybe if you keep trying then one day you'll
see your error.
It's now well-known that many animals with brains smaller than >Australopithencines make and use tools, so it's reasonable to suppose >Australopithecines did also.
The Wikipedia article on the subject makes a distinction between
object use, something that is found lying around and used as is, and
tool use, which is modified for the purpose its applied to.
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tool_use_by_animals>
For example, chimps strip leaves off sticks for termite-fishing.
The following video is of Jane Goodall recalling her witnessing for
the first time chimps making and using tools just 40 years ago:
<https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFbqeVXzra0>
"We were defined as man the toolmaker. And so now we had to
redefine man, redefine tools, or redefine chimpanzees as human." *********************************************************
A classic!
Termite fishing.
Sysop: | Keyop |
---|---|
Location: | Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, UK |
Users: | 498 |
Nodes: | 16 (2 / 14) |
Uptime: | 15:30:47 |
Calls: | 9,826 |
Calls today: | 5 |
Files: | 13,761 |
Messages: | 6,191,141 |