• Soil pipe move advice

    From AnthonyL@21:1/5 to All on Sun Mar 23 21:45:11 2025
    The soil pipe is quite a way in from the wall, 6" with the centre
    being 9"

    https://flic.kr/p/2qTDSg1

    We're looking at having a new toilet as part of a bathroom
    refurbishment and the suggestion is just to build a stud box.

    There are floorboards under the carpet. Is it usually a major
    exercise to have the pipe nearer the wall? 1968 build.


    --
    AnthonyL

    Why ever wait to finish a job before starting the next?

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Nick Finnigan@21:1/5 to AnthonyL on Mon Mar 24 08:57:42 2025
    On 23/03/2025 21:45, AnthonyL wrote:
    The soil pipe is quite a way in from the wall, 6" with the centre
    being 9"

    https://flic.kr/p/2qTDSg1

    We're looking at having a new toilet as part of a bathroom
    refurbishment and the suggestion is just to build a stud box.

    There are floorboards under the carpet. Is it usually a major
    exercise to have the pipe nearer the wall? 1968 build.

    If that is clay bend leading to a clay pipe through the wall, yes -
    someone might need to make a new joint inside the wall.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From alan_m@21:1/5 to AnthonyL on Mon Mar 24 09:48:26 2025
    On 23/03/2025 21:45, AnthonyL wrote:
    The soil pipe is quite a way in from the wall, 6" with the centre
    being 9"

    https://flic.kr/p/2qTDSg1

    We're looking at having a new toilet as part of a bathroom
    refurbishment and the suggestion is just to build a stud box.

    There are floorboards under the carpet. Is it usually a major
    exercise to have the pipe nearer the wall? 1968 build.




    Is this on the ground floor?

    If so does the soil pipe go up to a second floor, or if a bungalow up
    through the roof to be ventilated?

    From the photo - is that the base of the toilet next to it and if so
    how is the outflow to the toilet connected to this soil pipe?

    The lower part of the soil pipe appears to be clay and possibly to move
    it a PVC extension and new PVC sweeping bend would need to be fitted
    under the floor. How much work this would entail depends on what is
    under the floorboards and how many floorboards would have to be lifted
    to gain suitable access. The soil pipe under the floorboards may be
    buried under earth or may be in a concrete foundation raft.

    You may find that the builders have brought the soil pipe up beside the concrete footings which could/will extend much wider than the inside
    wall of the building.

    Joining plastic to clay is much easier these days than in 1968 with
    something like https://www.screwfix.com/p/floplast-underground-flexible-adaptor-120-136mm/19914?

    If the soil pipe goes through a ceiling to another floor or through the
    loft ideally that location would also need to be changed. A new hole
    through the ceiling. If it just goes up afterwards though the roof then
    a bend could be placed in the loft to avoid messing around with roof
    tiles etc.

    If a soil stack goes out of the roof and alternative may be to use an
    air admittance valve. https://www.drainagepipe.co.uk/soil-and-waste/how-to-use-an-air-admittance-valve/

    Are you planning to re-route all those other waste pipes if move the
    waste pipe.

    --
    mailto : news {at} admac {dot} myzen {dot} co {dot} uk

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Tricky Dicky@21:1/5 to AnthonyL on Mon Mar 24 12:17:53 2025
    AnthonyL <nospam@please.invalid> wrote:
    The soil pipe is quite a way in from the wall, 6" with the centre
    being 9"

    https://flic.kr/p/2qTDSg1

    We're looking at having a new toilet as part of a bathroom
    refurbishment and the suggestion is just to build a stud box.

    There are floorboards under the carpet. Is it usually a major
    exercise to have the pipe nearer the wall? 1968 build.



    The only time I have seen an arrangement like that is a solid concrete
    floor and if that is what is below the carpet and floor boards then forget
    it as it is major work for little gain.

    Richard

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From AnthonyL@21:1/5 to All on Mon Mar 24 19:19:15 2025
    On Mon, 24 Mar 2025 09:48:26 +0000, alan_m <junk@admac.myzen.co.uk>
    wrote:

    On 23/03/2025 21:45, AnthonyL wrote:
    The soil pipe is quite a way in from the wall, 6" with the centre
    being 9"

    https://flic.kr/p/2qTDSg1

    We're looking at having a new toilet as part of a bathroom
    refurbishment and the suggestion is just to build a stud box.

    There are floorboards under the carpet. Is it usually a major
    exercise to have the pipe nearer the wall? 1968 build.




    Is this on the ground floor?


    Yes.

    If so does the soil pipe go up to a second floor, or if a bungalow up
    through the roof to be ventilated?


    No, it is a bungalow.

    From the photo - is that the base of the toilet next to it and if so
    how is the outflow to the toilet connected to this soil pipe?


    Sorry for not being clearer. The toilet itself is to the right and
    contains the 'U' bend which terminates in the clay 'pot' that you see
    in the photo. That then goes underground. The outside of the
    bungalow is the wall on the left where the measuring tape starts from.

    The lower part of the soil pipe appears to be clay and possibly to move
    it a PVC extension and new PVC sweeping bend would need to be fitted
    under the floor. How much work this would entail depends on what is
    under the floorboards and how many floorboards would have to be lifted
    to gain suitable access. The soil pipe under the floorboards may be
    buried under earth or may be in a concrete foundation raft.


    To be clear the intention/hope was to move it to nearer the wall so
    that a new toilet would be flush with the wall and not leave the best
    part of a 6" gap.

    You may find that the builders have brought the soil pipe up beside the >concrete footings which could/will extend much wider than the inside
    wall of the building.

    Joining plastic to clay is much easier these days than in 1968 with
    something like >https://www.screwfix.com/p/floplast-underground-flexible-adaptor-120-136mm/19914?

    If the soil pipe goes through a ceiling to another floor or through the
    loft ideally that location would also need to be changed. A new hole
    through the ceiling. If it just goes up afterwards though the roof then
    a bend could be placed in the loft to avoid messing around with roof
    tiles etc.


    It doesn't as explained above.

    If a soil stack goes out of the roof and alternative may be to use an
    air admittance valve. >https://www.drainagepipe.co.uk/soil-and-waste/how-to-use-an-air-admittance-valve/


    The soil stack is not involved. We seem to have a strange arrangement
    where the sewage system is shared between adjoining properties and in
    our case the stack is attached to the detached bungalow that is to the
    left of the photo.

    Are you planning to re-route all those other waste pipes if move the
    waste pipe.


    Shouldn't be necessary, they all go into a drain the other side of the
    wall.


    --
    AnthonyL

    Why ever wait to finish a job before starting the next?

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Tricky Dicky@21:1/5 to AnthonyL on Tue Mar 25 14:09:00 2025
    AnthonyL <nospam@please.invalid> wrote:
    On Mon, 24 Mar 2025 09:48:26 +0000, alan_m <junk@admac.myzen.co.uk>
    wrote:

    On 23/03/2025 21:45, AnthonyL wrote:
    The soil pipe is quite a way in from the wall, 6" with the centre
    being 9"

    https://flic.kr/p/2qTDSg1

    We're looking at having a new toilet as part of a bathroom
    refurbishment and the suggestion is just to build a stud box.

    There are floorboards under the carpet. Is it usually a major
    exercise to have the pipe nearer the wall? 1968 build.




    Is this on the ground floor?


    Yes.

    If so does the soil pipe go up to a second floor, or if a bungalow up
    through the roof to be ventilated?


    No, it is a bungalow.

    From the photo - is that the base of the toilet next to it and if so
    how is the outflow to the toilet connected to this soil pipe?


    Sorry for not being clearer. The toilet itself is to the right and
    contains the 'U' bend which terminates in the clay 'pot' that you see
    in the photo. That then goes underground. The outside of the
    bungalow is the wall on the left where the measuring tape starts from.

    The lower part of the soil pipe appears to be clay and possibly to move
    it a PVC extension and new PVC sweeping bend would need to be fitted
    under the floor. How much work this would entail depends on what is
    under the floorboards and how many floorboards would have to be lifted
    to gain suitable access. The soil pipe under the floorboards may be
    buried under earth or may be in a concrete foundation raft.


    To be clear the intention/hope was to move it to nearer the wall so
    that a new toilet would be flush with the wall and not leave the best
    part of a 6" gap.

    You may find that the builders have brought the soil pipe up beside the
    concrete footings which could/will extend much wider than the inside
    wall of the building.

    Joining plastic to clay is much easier these days than in 1968 with
    something like
    https://www.screwfix.com/p/floplast-underground-flexible-adaptor-120-136mm/19914?

    If the soil pipe goes through a ceiling to another floor or through the
    loft ideally that location would also need to be changed. A new hole
    through the ceiling. If it just goes up afterwards though the roof then
    a bend could be placed in the loft to avoid messing around with roof
    tiles etc.


    It doesn't as explained above.

    If a soil stack goes out of the roof and alternative may be to use an
    air admittance valve.
    https://www.drainagepipe.co.uk/soil-and-waste/how-to-use-an-air-admittance-valve/


    The soil stack is not involved. We seem to have a strange arrangement
    where the sewage system is shared between adjoining properties and in
    our case the stack is attached to the detached bungalow that is to the
    left of the photo.

    Are you planning to re-route all those other waste pipes if move the
    waste pipe.


    Shouldn't be necessary, they all go into a drain the other side of the
    wall.



    We had a similar toilet in our last house where a kitchen extension was
    built on the site of an old wash house and exterior toilet the toilet or at least it’s waste plumbing was retained and a new toilet was included in the extension. Like yours the clay waste was some distance from the wall and necessitated a separate cistern connected to the pan with a flush pipe. As
    I said before it is going to be an expensive job for little gain and
    basically it means you cannot use a close coupled toilet.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From alan_m@21:1/5 to Tricky Dicky on Tue Mar 25 18:05:05 2025
    On 25/03/2025 14:09, Tricky Dicky wrote:

    We had a similar toilet in our last house where a kitchen extension was
    built on the site of an old wash house and exterior toilet the toilet or at least it’s waste plumbing was retained and a new toilet was included in the extension. Like yours the clay waste was some distance from the wall and necessitated a separate cistern connected to the pan with a flush pipe. As
    I said before it is going to be an expensive job for little gain and basically it means you cannot use a close coupled toilet.



    It may be possible to connect a close coupled toilet using something like https://www.toolstation.com/swan-neck-pan-connector/p23824
    (the long bit can be cut down and the rubber seal pushed back on)
    or
    https://www.toolstation.com/90-pan-connector/p37429
    or
    https://www.toolstation.com/viva-slinky-fit-flexible-pan-connector/p90210

    But it would need some research into the actual dimensions of the pan
    and plan on paper if your joining pieces have a chance of fitting before
    buying anything expensive

    Gotchas
    i) Many toilet manufactures don't give all the dimensions you may
    require, especially how far from the wall the output is located.
    ii) You probably cannot use a fully enclosed toilet because you will
    need to have full access to get your hand behind the back of the pan to
    make sure the push on connections are made.
    iii) The photo probably shows a cement seal - the chances are that you
    have to remove it and it's probably a (fragile) clay pipe on one side.
    It may be cast iron but that also can be very brittle if you hit it with
    a hammer or chisel

    Something I've posted before
    If you do replace don't go for modern designer toilets, don't go for
    toilets with square seats. Go for a traditional style toilet and check
    any reviews for poor flushing.

    I've had a square continental style toilet with an internal shelf at the
    front. You tend to always poo on the shelf and _always_ need a brush to
    clean up after a flush. You can get splash back when peeing. The square
    shape means that you cannot easily straddle the bowl to direct the pee
    further back. Square seats tend to be unique to the manufacturer and
    even a modest priced toilet requires you to re-mortgage your house for a replacement seat 🙂
    --
    mailto : news {at} admac {dot} myzen {dot} co {dot} uk

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)