• Re: Different effectiveness between extractor and dehumidifier

    From Nick Finnigan@21:1/5 to Mike Halmarack on Tue Mar 25 08:53:14 2025
    On 25/03/2025 08:24, Mike Halmarack wrote:
    Been given advice to add powered extractors in bathroom and kitchen.
    the idea of using expensive electricity to heat rooms, and then using
    more expensive electricity to blow that heat out into the outside
    world is daunting.

    Would using a powered dehumidifier in rooms where activities produce
    water vapour not be just as effective without throwing out the heat?

    Yes, but not in the Summer.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Andy Burns@21:1/5 to Mike Halmarack on Tue Mar 25 08:39:11 2025
    Mike Halmarack wrote:

    Been given advice to add powered extractors in bathroom and kitchen.
    the idea of using expensive electricity to heat rooms, and then using
    more expensive electricity to blow that heat out into the outside
    world is daunting.

    I don't know whether single-room MVHR is effective (cost-wise or humidity-wise)?

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Theo@21:1/5 to Andy Burns on Tue Mar 25 09:47:48 2025
    Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
    Mike Halmarack wrote:

    Been given advice to add powered extractors in bathroom and kitchen.
    the idea of using expensive electricity to heat rooms, and then using
    more expensive electricity to blow that heat out into the outside
    world is daunting.

    I don't know whether single-room MVHR is effective (cost-wise or humidity-wise)?

    They claim to recover about 75% of the heat. That means you can run them in trickle mode without losing too much, which is important in a bathroom where
    it might get uncomfortably cold if a regular fan were venting to the wintry outside.

    Extractor fans that blow out need the air replacing from somewhere. If you don't open a window it'll come from inside the house somehow, which will
    likely mean cold air will come in via air leaks. You might not feel the bathroom being cold unless the bathroom itself leaks, but some other spot
    will get colder because of it.

    Dehumidifiers will reduce moisture, but they won't do anything for air
    quality - cooking, 'toilet smells', pet/human odours, gas hob. The
    advantage of MVHR is you're simultaneously pulling in fresh outside air
    instead of recirculating stale inside air.

    Single room MVHR are a bit expensive for what they are. I have a used one
    of these to play with: https://www.i-sells.co.uk/product/vent-axia-lo-carbon-tempra-single-room-heat-recovery-unit/

    The actual heat exchanger (available as a spare) is a tube of plastic
    straws. That connects with a double sided fan - one side of the fan blows
    air down the straws, the other side sucks air in from the side of the tube which is connected to the space between the straws, resulting in opposite directions air passing each other across the surface of the straws.

    The trouble is the fan is loud (perhaps because it's used, but I don't think so) and I need to work out how to quieten it down, which is awkward. There
    are some hacks here: https://www.earth.org.uk/MHRV-Vent-Axia-Lo-Carbon-Tempra-P-REVIEW.html https://homefarmparham.co.uk/HomeFarmHouse/fittings/Vent-Axia/VentAxiaTempraMods.html

    It's a custom 24V PWM fan controlled by a little control board with a PIC
    micro that does timer, humidity, etc, and if you get the non-SELV version a 240V->24V PSU board. The uplift on the humidity/timer/etc version is ridiculously pricy for such a simple board - a standard PWM fan controller might do it, or an Arduino.

    But even at lowest PWM it's not quiet enough for me. The other option is
    just to DIY an equivalent, perhaps with a matrix of copper tubes like a
    steam loco boiler. But I need to work out how to do a tangential/cross-flow fan (pulls air across the fan blades like a water wheel) as that doesn't
    seem to be a thing you can easily buy in a flat form factor, only a long cylinder.

    Theo

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Vir Campestris@21:1/5 to Nick Finnigan on Tue Mar 25 11:18:33 2025
    On 25/03/2025 08:53, Nick Finnigan wrote:
    On 25/03/2025 08:24, Mike Halmarack wrote:
    Been given advice to add powered extractors in bathroom and kitchen.
    the idea of using expensive electricity to heat rooms, and then using
    more expensive electricity to blow that heat out into the outside
    world is daunting.

    Would using a powered dehumidifier in rooms where activities produce
    water vapour not be just as effective without throwing out the heat?

     Yes, but not in the Summer.

    We have a heat pump tumbler drier which lives in my workshop - no decent
    space in the house.

    Obviously when the weather is nice and dry and sunny it doesn't get
    used. A washing line does the job.

    It doesn't condense 100% of the water out of the exhaust. The room gets
    warm and perceptibly damp - which I don't think my tools (or the car in
    the attached garage!) would like very much.

    In summer we put on an extractor fan. It sucks out the warm damp air,
    and warm dry air comes in at the opposite end.

    In winter we put on a dehumidifier. It dries the air, and the power
    consumed by both devices make the workshop nice and warm.

    Andy

    --
    Do not listen to rumour, but, if you do, do not believe it.
    Ghandi.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Adam Funk@21:1/5 to Mike Halmarack on Tue Mar 25 15:51:14 2025
    On 2025-03-25, Mike Halmarack wrote:

    Been given advice to add powered extractors in bathroom and kitchen.
    the idea of using expensive electricity to heat rooms, and then using
    more expensive electricity to blow that heat out into the outside
    world is daunting.

    Would using a powered dehumidifier in rooms where activities produce
    water vapour not be just as effective without throwing out the heat?

    Maybe in the bathroom (except for smells), but only specialist
    dehumidifiers meet the requirements for UK bathroom installation and
    from what I recall they are rather expensive.

    In the kitchen, you definitely want air (including grease, fumes from
    burning gas, etc., as well as water vapour) sucked out.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From David Wade@21:1/5 to Adam Funk on Tue Mar 25 16:59:05 2025
    On 25/03/2025 15:51, Adam Funk wrote:
    On 2025-03-25, Mike Halmarack wrote:

    Been given advice to add powered extractors in bathroom and kitchen.
    the idea of using expensive electricity to heat rooms, and then using
    more expensive electricity to blow that heat out into the outside
    world is daunting.

    Would using a powered dehumidifier in rooms where activities produce
    water vapour not be just as effective without throwing out the heat?

    Maybe in the bathroom (except for smells), but only specialist
    dehumidifiers meet the requirements for UK bathroom installation and
    from what I recall they are rather expensive.

    In the kitchen, you definitely want air (including grease, fumes from
    burning gas, etc., as well as water vapour) sucked out.

    If only Water Vapour was the actual problem in the bathroom.....

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Andy Burns@21:1/5 to Theo on Wed Mar 26 08:58:08 2025
    Theo wrote:

    https://www.i-sells.co.uk/product/vent-axia-lo-carbon-tempra-single- room-heat-recovery-unit/

    The actual heat exchanger (available as a spare) is a tube of plastic
    straws.

    How do straws fail?

    The other option is just to DIY an equivalent, perhaps with a matrix
    of copper tubes like a steam loco boiler.

    Maybe stacked layers of coroplast board, with alternating hot/out going
    left to right and cold/in going back to front, then some sort of 3D
    printed 45° manifold?

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Theo@21:1/5 to Andy Burns on Wed Mar 26 11:53:52 2025
    Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
    Theo wrote:

    https://www.i-sells.co.uk/product/vent-axia-lo-carbon-tempra-single- room-heat-recovery-unit/

    The actual heat exchanger (available as a spare) is a tube of plastic straws.

    How do straws fail?

    No idea, but they appear to have spares for everything. Perhaps they get clogged with muck?

    The other option is just to DIY an equivalent, perhaps with a matrix
    of copper tubes like a steam loco boiler.

    Maybe stacked layers of coroplast board, with alternating hot/out going
    left to right and cold/in going back to front, then some sort of 3D
    printed 45° manifold?

    For decent heat transfer you need the walls to be as thin as possible, or
    made of heat conducting material. I'd guess coroplast is thicker plastic as it's designed to be sturdy?

    The Tempra has outlet (from the room) on the sides and inlet on the bottom
    to prevent airflows mixing, with a flap to close the bottom so you can stop
    it letting in hot air in the summer. I'd guess you might need to do
    something similar - inlet in one plane and outlet in another. A nice big ~120mm outlet fan on the face of the unit is easy, I suppose you could side mount a
    smaller ~60-80mm fan for the inlet if you didn't mind a deep unit.

    Theo

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)
  • From Adam Funk@21:1/5 to David Wade on Fri Mar 28 15:15:14 2025
    On 2025-03-25, David Wade wrote:

    On 25/03/2025 15:51, Adam Funk wrote:
    On 2025-03-25, Mike Halmarack wrote:

    Been given advice to add powered extractors in bathroom and kitchen.
    the idea of using expensive electricity to heat rooms, and then using
    more expensive electricity to blow that heat out into the outside
    world is daunting.

    Would using a powered dehumidifier in rooms where activities produce
    water vapour not be just as effective without throwing out the heat?

    Maybe in the bathroom (except for smells), but only specialist
    dehumidifiers meet the requirements for UK bathroom installation and
    from what I recall they are rather expensive.

    In the kitchen, you definitely want air (including grease, fumes from
    burning gas, etc., as well as water vapour) sucked out.

    If only Water Vapour was the actual problem in the bathroom.....

    Well, I did say "except for smells"! They are unlikely to be a hazard
    (just an inconvenience), whereas condensation causes mould (which can
    get dangerous) and damage to grout, sealant, etc.

    --- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
    * Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)